Reading Response #2

to Artful Design • Chapter 2: “Designing Expressive Toys”

Renee Q.

October 4, 2024

Music 256A / CS 476A, Stanford University

—

In this week’s reading on Artful Design’s Chapter 2: Designing Expressive Toys, Principle 2.2: “Design Inside-Out” resonated with me. This creation process, beginning from the core functionality of a product and extending outward to its interface and user experience, is an interesting way to approach design. Unlike other design processes that prioritize aesthetics or market demands first, this principle encourages us to start with the intrinsic capabilities and constraints of technology and creatively expand outward to discover new possibilities and functionalities.

An intriguing example that comes to mind is the Theremin, one of the earliest electronic musical instruments, which I had the opportunity to explore from a foundational level by building it as a final project in a Stanford class called Musical Acoustics.

The Theremin is uniquely played without physical contact; instead, it operates on the principles of capacitance and electromagnetic fields. This instrument’s design began with its core technological capability — the ability to sense the relative position of the player’s hands to control pitch and volume. When the investor, Leon Theremin, discovered that the body could act as a variable capacitor when placed near an electromagnetic field, this core functionality — detecting hand movements through changes in capacitance — became the basis for the entire design. From this point, the instrument was developed outward: Theremin added antennas (one for pitch and one for volume) and refined the electronic circuits to translate these capacitive changes into audible sound waves. Then, Voila! The result was an instrument that offered a new, expressive way of interacting with music, which not only capitalized on the intrinsic properties of the electromagnetic fields and human interaction but also expanded the possibilities of musical performance and composition.

​​  

I think Theremin’s design illustrates how starting with a basic physical principle can lead to the creation of entirely new forms of artistic expression. As such, this aligns with the inside-out design philosophy, where the design process explores and maximizes the inherent capabilities of the core technology, leading to innovative and unexpected applications.

Overall, “Design Inside-Out” offers a perspective on how understanding and embracing the foundational aspects of technology can lead to innovations that go beyond the intended use of a tool. It teaches us that by focusing on the core functionalities and allowing room for user-driven adaptation, we can create designs that are not only functional but also inspiring and capable of evolving in unexpected ways. This principle will definitely continue to influence my approach to designing new musical interfaces and interactive systems.